Do
you love mysteries and thrillers but feel a bit burnt out by them, as if you’re
reading the same book with a different setting over and over? Or have you read
all your favorite series and now wait around for the next release, randomly
picking up other books like filler? Or have you never really read much in the
genre and want to start, but don’t know where?
Try
alternating a new release with a classic or significant back list title. Mix it
up further by cycling in subgenres that you haven’t yet tried: cozy, hard
boiled, medical, legal, western, LGBT, espionage, supernatural, etc.
The
beauty of reading this way is that you stay in touch with what’s current, yet
learn about the history of the genre and subgenres. You’ll expose yourself to
new-to-you authors and may discover that a subgenre you’ve avoided actually
interests you. Through reading older titles you’ll come to have a deeper
appreciation for newer releases because you’ll understand the tradition from
which they’ve grown. You’ll be able to see when a new release does something
original. Or how, perhaps, it fails to live up to the demands of the genre or
subgenre.
This
approach works well for independent reading or for book groups. I used it in a
past book group and my current group is using it. This month we read Tana
French’s new release, The Secret Place.
Next month we’re going back to 1868 for The Moonstone by Willie Collins which
is considered the first mystery novel. After that we’ll read Still
Life by Louise Penny (2006) and then Cover
Her Face by P.D. James (1962). We’ll discuss the merits and pitfalls of
each novel in and of itself (the mystery, plot, characters, etc), and then also
discuss which subgenre(s) it fits into and how well.
There
is no right or wrong to reading this way.
But
crime fiction is such a huge category, so where to begin? Your local librarian
can certainly point you in the right direction. Or a simple internet search for
“mystery subgenres” or “history of mystery” will pull up helpful information
from which you can begin creating your own reading list. There are even books
and lists of the top 50 or 100 mystery/thrillers everyone should read.
Another
option is to check out the websites of organizations like The Mystery Writers
of America, the Crime Writers’ Association, or International Thriller Writers.
Compare their lists of award winning books. Look at the Agatha Award list for
the best cozies or the Shamus Award list for the best PI novels.
After
a while you see the same titles showing up across various lists and will feel
the need to read that book.
If
you enjoy audiobooks there’s a course from The Modern Scholar series that your
library may carry or be able to get for you called Detective Fiction: From Victorian Sleuths
to the Present by Professor M. Lee Alexander which explores the origins of
the genre, significant eras, subgenres, and trends. You can download the course
booklet from the website linked above. It’s an excellent resource.
I
hope this method jazzes up your mystery/thriller reading or gets you started.
I’d love hear about what strategy you use to read around in this vast and
diverse genre.
I looove thrillers (I know, you'd never guess looking at my blog...) and I'm so glad I started reading through the ITW list of 100 must-reads. Not all of them have lived up to that title, for me, but I've also read some great older books I might never have read otherwise. Rebecca, Strangers on a Train, and Eye of the Needle immediately come to mind as classics that I loved, and first picked up because of this list.
ReplyDeleteIn an ITW interview David Morrell mentioned looking at Dracula as the first serial killer novel if you take out the supernatural bits. I love that! I've been meaning to give Rebecca another chance. I tried it years ago and it wasn't the right time.
Deleteanother way would be to read thrillers translated from other languages, there are some really good ones from the French and the Japanese for sure
ReplyDeleteThat's a great suggestion! And what an interesting way to learn about another country...looking at how a mystery is approached or how a thriller situation is handled.
DeleteI love this idea too, I love mysteries and reading about different countries (I am one of the co-hosts for tge Travel the World in Books reading challenge). Do you have specific recommendations of mysteries from French or Japanese authors?
DeleteGreat post and tips, Chris. Thank you for sharing today!
ReplyDeleteThanks for having me, Becca!
DeleteI have been wanting to get back into reading mysteries. I read a couple current releases but do love going back to the classics like Sherlock Holmes and Agatha Christie.
ReplyDeleteMe, too, Tanya. I just read The Moonstone and loved it. I've only read two Agatha Christie novels, but recently snapped up a few more at library sales.
DeleteGREAT suggestions Chris!! I love mixing things up, but didn't even think about purposefully doing it for a book group. I love that idea!
ReplyDeleteThanks! The new book group I'm in loves reading mysteries this way.
Delete